Trapped Between Two Alphas

(Annabel POV)

My order finally arrived! Not that I had been waiting that long, but you know how it is when you order something, you want it to arrive immediately.

I've been cooped up in my art room for days. I had a deadline today at noon and I luckily met it in time. So now I could finally relax and have some fun.

I glanced at the screen of my phone. It was 1pm in the afternoon, so actually it was the perfect time to open my package and explore the content. Kaden would still be at his office for a good few hours. And since it was Friday today, he would probably do some extra hours, wrapping up loose ends.

I was really happy I decided to do my art full-time, now I chose my own hour and I worked from home. I was also just doing what I loved. Most of my time was spent on commissions. The deadline earlier today was for one of those. But I was also painting some pieces for myself, so I could do a solo exhibition one day. I still needed to add a lot of pieces and redo some of my old work, because I wasn't happy with it anymore.

I took some scissors and opened up the package very carefully. After digging through the layers of red tissue paper, I finally found my items and placed them on the table. Before me were cat ears, a choker and a tail. I'd been wanting to try pet play and found this little set online. I couldn't resist the temptation to buy it.

The cat ears were attached to a kind of headband, so they would stay put once you put them on. They were beautifully made with black lace pieces as decorations. I found myself studying them quite closely. The artist in me really appreciated these little details. The choker also was really interesting. It had a chain that came with it, so it also doubled as a collar.

Thinking about the fun I was going to have later, I started to get a little turned on already. Would Kaden be surprised if he would see me as a kitty? Would he let me see that soft dom side of him again, that only appears every once in a while? We never really discussed any of this, so I hoped he would also be into it. Our sex life had been a little slow lately and I missed being intimate. But tonight that would change.. I hoped, and if it didn't, I would talk to him about it. Like they say, communication is key.

The last item was the tabby tail. It had patches of black, grey and white. It was attached to a small buttplug. I got a little nervous looking at it. I'd never had a buttplug in me before, but there was no other way to attach the tail. It was weirdly thrilling that I was going to use it in a little bit. I liked trying out new things. You can't know you don't like it, if you've never tried it.

First, it was time for a nice and long shower, though. I moved the items from the table to the bedroom, so I could do my prep there after I showered. I took my time under the water, I made sure to massage my muscles. I'd been so cramped up, since I tended to work in really weird positions. But everything to get a good result, I suppose. I stepped out from under the water and wrapped a fluffy towel around my body. I didn’t bother getting dressed and just walked into the bedroom like that.

My hair was only a little damp, because I had tried to blow-dry it. I put on the cat ears and inspected myself in the full length mirror that stood against the wall. It looked really cute. I followed that up with the choker, but didn't add the chain yet. It would just get in the way for now, and I wasn't sure if I wanted to try that today anyway.

I went over to my nightstand and opened the bottom drawer, to look for my lube. I might have been inexperienced with anal stuff, but I was smart enough to know how to use a lot of lubrication. I took the plug and covered it with a generous amount of lube. I made sure to cover the entire thing, just to be safe. At first, I tried to put it in, while still standing up. But I was having some difficulty like that. I couldn't hold it properly, since the attached tail made it a bit more unwieldy.

I went to get comfortable on the bed. That would make it easier, since I could maneuver a bit more laying down. I put the buttplug against my ass and slowly pushed it in. I kept going until it reached to base and it was completely in.

It was a little uncomfortable and felt invasive. But since it was a small one, it wasn't too bad. It didn't hurt or anything. Once I passed the widest part, it actually went in on its own. That kinda surprised me, I hadn't expected that.

I stood up and inspected myself in the mirror. The movement carried the plug along. I still wasn't sure how I felt about the sensation. Looking at the whole picture in the mirror, I had to admit it was quite erotic. I turned around to get a better look at the tail.

"Well, isn't this a sight to behold? I have to say, I wasn't expecting to see this at all,” Kaden mused. "Kaden? You're back earlier than I expected,” I said while turning to face him, getting a little flushed. He had a little smirk on his face. "I thought something was weird when I saw this chain on the table."

He approached me, but it wasn't his normal way of walking. It felt more like he was a predator approaching it's prey. He also had this gleam in his eyes I hadn't seen before. It made me feel like I was in danger. But on the other hand, it was also exceptionally thrilling.

I looked up at him, when he stood in front of me. He leaned down to kiss me. But instead of kissing me on the mouth, he pressed his lips against my cheek. I closed me eyes and just enjoyed the sensations. He didn’t touch me anywhere else. The only thing I felt was his trail of kisses, leading to my neck. When he reached it, he bit down a little. It hurt a little bit, but the adrenaline rush I had, made it just feel kinda... good... I also just enjoyed a little pain with my pleasure.

I moaned softly and suddenly I heard a snap. I'd been too distracted to notice his wandering hands. While kissing me, he had attached the chain to my choker. He suddenly stood up straight again. "What are you doing to me? If you keep on looking at me like that, I can't predict what will happen,” he said, while pulling me towards the bed.

He sat down and reached over for a pillow and put it at his feet.

"Kaden, what's going on? I didn't think you'd react like this," I said kinda shyly.

I was suddenly feeling very aware. He looked me up and down and inspected me closely. He tugged at the chain again.

"Aren't you a kitty?" He was teasing me.

"Well... yes," I stammered.

"Well, then be a good kitty and sit down on your hands and knees on the floor. I've never seen a kitty standing up.”

I obliged, but I was also a little intimidated. He must have been on edge, since he was acting like this.

"Come and have some milk. And put your knees on the pillow,” he ordered me.

He was being very commanding, but he was still so considerate at the same time. Some things just didn't change, I guess.

I crawled forward and did what I was told. At this point, I was already used to the feeling of having the buttplug inside of me. I put my hands on his thick thighs and went to unzip his pants.

"What do you think you're doing? Do cats have “hands’? They don't, Kitty, they have paws. And they can't unzip anything with them, last time I checked. So do your best and use your teeth." He was laughing at me.

I'd show him. With my hands on his thighs again, I leaned my head forward and bit down on the pull tab of his zipper. I slowly pulled it down. I glanced up at him and could see he was watching me with eagle eyes. With a little smirk, I bit softly in the bulge of his pants. He was still holding the chain in his left hand and with his right, he grabbed my hair. He pulled my head backwards, but not too forcefully.

"Bad little kitty, now don't go and bite the hand that feeds you,” he growled.

He let go of the chain for a bit so he could undo the button on his pants. After that, he pulled out his erection.

"Open that little mouth of yours and stick out your tongue. It's time for your milk," he said, while he pushed my head forwards again.

I knew what he wanted and I wanted to give it to him. He usually wasn't one to talk dirty, but he was going beyond my wildest imagination right now. I could feel myself getting a little wet hearing those words.

I put my mouth at the tip of his penis and started sucking gently. His hand in my hair made sure I couldn't go anywhere, but he wasn't forcing me to take his erection deeper in my mouth. It was like he just wanted me to stay put, but still go at my own pace.

"Can I at least use my hands now? You're too big to fit in my mouth entirely and I don't want to get hurt or choke or something,” I was pouting.

"Of course, Kitty. I would never want to hurt you. And I want you to be able to enjoy what I'm going to do to you after this," he said.

With one of my hands, I grabbed the base of his penis. The other hand I kept on his thigh, so I could keep my balance. I lowered my head once more, this time taking him a little deeper in my mouth. I started a rhythm bopping my head and moving my hand at the same time.

"Just a little longer,” he groaned. "But don't you dare move your head when I'm cumming. Swallow all my milk."

I drove up the rhythm a little bit and soon he started moaning. There was just something so pleasing about making my partner be vocal about his pleasure. He was usually very quiet, so hearing him moan was a huge turn on.

He shivered his release and I swallowed every last drop of his cum, like the good little kitty I was supposed to be.

"That was amazing, Sweetheart. You did really good, so now I can reward you. You did such a good job, Pet.”

He reclined on the bed and like that, his upper body was completely on the bed. He tugged at the chain. I took that as the sign to crawl on top of him.

"Come and take your seat. You're almost there, just a bit higher,” he smiled deviously. "I know you prefer when I'm laying between your thighs, but sit on my face. Now. And don't hold back, just grind on me."

When I was trying to get into the position Kaden had asked me to by crawling over him, he suddenly grabbed my waist. He moved his hands to my neck and undid the chain from the collar. Then he threw it aside, so it wouldn't be in the way. After that, he trailed his hand down to my waist again.